Consent in medical practice


 

Consent:

Section 13 of Indian Contract Act defines that two or more persons are said to consent when they agree upon the same thing in the same sense.

Types

According to the information provided to the patient by the doctor

1. Informed

2. Uninformed

Uninformed consent is illegal unless it falls within the concept of therapeutic privilege.

Informed consent means consent for any procedure or treatment after fully informing about his condition.

Components of informed consent:

Disclosure: Full disclosure of information which is material to a decision.

Comprehension: Complete understanding of information disclosed

Absence of outside control

Competence: The person should be competent to give consent

Actual consent: It should be in writing with signature of the patient and two independent witnesses.

According to the patient communicates to the doctor

1. Implied.

2. Express (i) Oral, (ii) Written

Implied consent: This type of consent is specifically stated by the patient and is seen in routine medical practice and is quite adequate. In these situations, consent is implied in the sense that patient has come to physician with a physical condition or ailment for examination and treatment. When a patient holds out his arm for an injection it is implied consent. If the procedure is simple and the risk is negligible implied consent is enough but if there is the slightest fear of complication, the doctor should seek express consent.

Express consent: May be written or verbal, and should be obtained for any procedure beyond the routine physical examination, like operation, blood transfusion etc. The nature and consequences of the procedure should be explained before obtaining consent.

In informed consent, the doctor informs the patient about his/her condition or disease, nature of the proposed treatment, availability of any alternative procedure, the possible risks and benefits of the procedure and the percentage of chances of success and failure.

The patient should be explained in a simple language that he can understand fully and give consent in the presence of third party who acts as a witness. Once the consent is obtained any untoward reaction or harm cause to the patient cannot lead to charge of negligence for the doctor.

Blanket consent: Consent taken for any or every diagnostic or therapeutic procedures that might have to be taken in future. This type of consent is invalid.

Proxy/surrogate consent: Consent given by a relative, next to kin or friend in cases where the patient himself cannot give like in case of consent taken for a person of unsound mind.

Exceptions to the informed consent:

Emergency (Section 92 I.P.C.): In an emergency condition it is usually assumed that the patient will give consent. In these cases, the consent is taken as implied.

Therapeutic privilege: In this category the physician can be excused of obtaining informed consent when disclosure of information could have a detrimental effect on the patient.

Informed refusal: The doctor has a duty to inform the patient that he has a right to refuse the treatment or investigations to be undertaken. After listening to the doctor, the patient can refuse to consent for the proposed investigation/treatment.

The consent should be full, free, voluntary, clear, informed, and direct. There should be no undue influence, fraud, and misrepresentation of the facts, compulsion and threat of physical injury, death, or other consequences. The doctor should inform the patient that he has the right to refuse to submit himself to the examination and that the results may go against him /her.

#consent #medicolegal #legalmedicine

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Postmortem Changes- Immediate and Early

Image
  Postmortem changes   1.  Immediate changes:   (i) Unconsciousness and loss of reflexes (ii) Permanent cessation of cir­culation (iii) Permanent cessation of respiration. 2.  Early changes:   (i)  Eye changes (ii)  Skin changes (iii)  Muscular flaccidity (iv)  Postmortem lividity (v)  Cooling of the body (vi)  Rigor mortis. 3 .  Late changes:   (i)  Putrefaction (ii)  Adipocere (iii)  Mummification.   Immediate changes Unconsciousness and Loss of Reflexes There is loss of consciousness and spinal reflexes with no response to painful stimuli. Permanent  C essation of Circulation and Respiration This is ascertained by the careful examination of heart and lungs by stethoscope for 5 minutes that is repeated at short intervals.   Early changes   Changes in the eyes 1 . Changes in cornea:   After death, the eyeballs become softened, cornea loses its luster, and the corneal reflex is ...
Read more

Datura Poisoning

Image
  Datura Two varieties: (i) Datura Alba—White flowers (ii) Datura Niger— B lack or deep purple flowers. The fruits are spherical with sharp spines— Thorn apple and contains yellowish  brown seeds.   All parts of the plant are poi­so­nous, but the fruit and seeds are most  poisonous. Active Principles: (i) Hyoscine (ii) Hyoscya­mine (iii) Traces of atropine. Mechanism of action: The symptoms are due to the blockade of peripheral  muscarinic receptors that innervate exocrine glands, smooth muscle, and cardiac  tissue. Therefore, the primary toxic manifestations include mydriasis, which is due  to the blockade of papillary sphincter muscle and iris muscle; dry mouth,  secondary to parasympathetic blockade of salivary secretion; tachycardia, caused  by competition at muscarinic receptors in postganglionic parasympathetic neurons  and blockade of receptors in the SA node; and fever and erythema, because of  vasodilation and in...
Read more

Phosphorus Poisoning

  Phosphorus Phosphorus is used in the manufacture of matches, fireworks, rodenticide, and fertilizers. Three forms of phosphorus are available white, red, and black. Yellow phosphorus is formed by a small amount of red phosphorus resulting discoloration of white phosphorus. Mechanism of action: It affects cellular oxidation, and it is highly corrosive and is also a general cellular poison. Cardiovascular collapse occurring after ingestion results not only from fluid loss caused by vomiting and diarrhea but also from a direct toxic effect on the heart and vascular tone. Sign and symptoms: Ingestion of elemental white or yellow phosphorus typically causes severe vomiting and diarrhea, having a garlic-like odor. Other signs and symptoms of severe poisoning are dysrhythmias, coma, hypotension, and death. It can also cause liver become swollen, fatty, and soft suggestive of acute liver atrophy etc. Fatal dose: 60-120 mg Fatal Period: 2-8 days Treatment: Gastric lavage u...
Read more